Common car insurance myths

Jason Barker • January 2, 2024

Every day, we have customers phoning up or coming in to see us, bewildered about things their insurance companies have told them. We endeavour to make sure everyone knows their rights when it comes to insurance issues, making for a stress-free repair process, should the worst happen.


  1. You must take your vehicle to a repair centre specified by your insurance company – False! Following an incident, your insurance company is likely to tell you that you must take your vehicle to one of their approved repair centres, regardless of the distance between your address and the garage itself! We’ve seen many customers sending their vehicles to towns and cities a substantial distance away from them for repair, when they didn’t need to!

    In reality, it is your right to take your vehicle to any repair centre of your choosing. We always recommend doing your due diligence to select a reputable repair centre and staying local where possible – visit out blog ‘
    What are the benefits of using a local repairer?’ for further information.

  2. Your insurance company will only repair your car with new and genuine parts – Not true! If you did decide to go with your insurance company’s recommended approved repairer, your insurer may have granted them the use of non-genuine and/or used parts. Whilst this may result in a lower repair cost, it may also compromise the safety of your vehicle.

    It’s worth checking your insurance policy documents to see exactly what you’ve agreed to.

  3. Personal car insurance covers business use – Many people are unaware that their insurance policy doesn’t cover them for business use in line with their job role. If you’re travelling to more than one place during a day for your job, you may need to purchase additional business coverage.

  4. Claiming on your insurance policy will always result in a significant increase in your premiums – Incorrect! We see so many customers here at CARS, and many are hesitant to claim on their insurance policies, even after major accidents! People tend to assume that making a claim will result in an extortionate rise in premium costs but in reality, the premium is likely to go up by a minimal amount, if at all. For example, we might estimate that it costs £2,500 to repair damage to your vehicle. It’s almost impossible for your insurance to go up by this amount. As a result, making a claim might be in your best interests.

  5. Your premium will automatically decrease each year – Sadly, no. Many people assume that their insurance premium will go down on renewal each year. However, research has shown that insurance costs are on the rise – visit our blog ‘Is the cost of car insurance going up?’ for further information.

    There are also many other reasons your premium may increase, such as change of address, change in vehicle or change in occupation, among others. We also encourage our customers to do their research before accepting the auto-renewal price supplied by their insurers, as there may be cheaper options available.
By Ebony Morgan • October 23, 2026
Find out what affects your car’s part-exchange value, including age, mileage, condition, service history, specification and current market demand.
Best Used Cars Under £10,000
By Ebony Morgan • October 20, 2026
Looking for the best used car under £10,000? Find out what your budget could buy and how to choose a used car that offers good value for money.
By Ebony Morgan • October 14, 2026
Vehicle history checks provide valuable information when buying a used car, but they have limitations. Find out what they can reveal and what else you should check.
By Ebony Morgan • October 14, 2026
We are delighted to share that CARS of Grimsby was shortlisted as a finalist in the Family Fortunes category at The Business Hive’s Great Big Small Awards, which took place on 25th September.
Used car inspection guide
By Ebony Morgan • October 14, 2026
Buying a used car? Learn what to inspect before you buy, from bodywork and accident damage to service history and the test drive.
By Ebony Morgan • October 9, 2026
Why can two similar used cars have very different prices? Understand why condition, history, mileage, preparation and warranty can affect value.
By Ebony Morgan • September 29, 2026
Should you buy a used car privately or from a dealer? Compare the price, preparation, legal protection and support available with each option.
By Ebony Morgan • September 29, 2026
Compare main dealers and independent used car dealers, including vehicle choice, preparation, warranties, pricing and customer service.
By Ebony Morgan • September 22, 2026
How much should you spend on a used car? Learn how to set a realistic budget by considering the purchase price, finance and ongoing running costs.
By Ebony Morgan • September 21, 2026
Learn what RAC Approved Dealer status means when buying a used car, including vehicle checks, preparation standards, warranty and breakdown cover.
Show More