How Do I Challenge A Car Insurance Write-Off?

Jason Barker • June 30, 2023

Following an accident or other damage, your insurance company may decide that your vehicle is a ‘write-off’. In some circumstances, you do not have to accept this decision and are entitled to challenge your insurer.


If you are involved in an accident that was your fault and the cost of repair goes above 60-70% of the vehicle’s value, most insurers will write the vehicle off, stating that the vehicle is an uneconomical repair. This is because you are making a claim within the terms of your insurance policy, and most policies state a maximum repair cost of 60-70%.


However, if you are involved in an accident that wasn’t your fault (non-fault), we would advise claiming directly via the other party’s insurance. In most cases, you have a legal right to have the vehicle repaired up to 100% of its value, and at a repair centre of your choice – without penalties, or having to pay your excess.


There are occasions where the vehicle may be written off, regardless of cost. This may happen when the vehicle is categorised as ‘A’ or ‘B’. Please see our blog ‘What should I do if my vehicle is written off by my insurer?’ to find out how write-offs are categorised. 

By Ebony Barker January 16, 2026
Whether you're selling your car privately, part-exchanging it at a dealership, or preparing to return a lease vehicle, the way your car looks plays a huge role in how much it’s worth.
By Ebony Barker January 16, 2026
Even the most careful drivers pick up small bits of cosmetic damage over time, whether it’s a scuff in a supermarket car park, a kerbed alloy on a tight corner, or a stone chip from the motorway.
By Ebony Barker January 16, 2026
SMART repairs (Small-to-Medium Area Repair Technologies) are an incredibly popular way to fix minor cosmetic damage quickly and cost-effectively. However, not all SMART repairs are equal.
By Ebony Barker January 16, 2026
As we welcome the new year, many of us are thinking about fresh starts. For your vehicle, that can mean finally dealing with the small knocks and cosmetic damage that have built up over time.
By Ebony Barker December 2, 2025
At CARS, we’re always looking for ways to enhance our services with advanced solutions for our customers.
By Ebony Barker November 3, 2025
We would like to extend a huge well done to Callum for achieving his Technical Paint Training with the Volkswagen Group.
By Ebony Barker October 1, 2025
We would like to say an immense thank you to everyone that joined us for our Grand Opening Event on Saturday 30th August.
By Ebony Barker September 3, 2025
We would like to extend a huge well done to Paul for achieving his High Voltage Technician qualification with the Volkswagen Group.
By Ebony Barker September 3, 2025
We have some exciting news to share! 
Young person driving a car.
By Ebony Barker February 13, 2025
Understand young driver excess and how it impacts your car insurance premiums. CARS of Grimsby offers expert advice to help new drivers make informed choices.
Show More